Excerpt from:
Fluoride: The Aging Factor (2nd Edition)
Author: Dr. John Yiamouyiannis
Published: Health Action Press
Year: 1986 (first edition 1983, third edition 1993)
ISBN: 0-913571-01-6
(To order a copy of "Fluoride: The Aging
Factor" from Amazon click here.
If Amazon is out of stock, you can order a copy at http://www.nutech2000.com.au/prod3.htm.)
About the Author: Dr. John Yiamouyiannis was, until his death in the fall of 2000, the world's leading authority on the biological effects of fluoride. His formal education included a B.S. in biochemistry from the University of Chicago and a Ph.D in biochemistry from the University of Rhode Island. After a year of postdoctoral research at Western Reserve University Medical School, Yiamouyiannis went on to become biochemical editor at Chemical Abstracts Service, the world's largest chemical information center. It was at Chemical Abstracts Service, where Yiamouyiannis became interested in the damaging effects of fluoride.
Chapter 4 - Breaking Down the Body's Glue
All animals, including humans, are made up of
cells. The cell, the basic unit of life, can be identified under
a microscope by its outer membrane and a nucleus within the membrane.
Some cells are able to produce a protein called collagen. In this
book, the term "collagen" refers to collagen as well as
collagen-like proteins. This process occurs inside the cell. Little
globules called vesicles carry the collagen from the inside of the
cell to the cell membrane where it is released to the outside of
the cell. There, the collagen thickens into fibers.
The five different types of cells capable of producing and releasing
collagen in this way are:
- fibroblasts, which produce collagen for the
structural support of skin, tendons, ligaments and muscle;
- chondroblasts, which produce collagen for the
structual support of cartilage;
- osteoblasts, which produce collagen for the
structual foundation and framework upon which calcium and phosphate
are deposited, giving rise to bone;
- ameloblasts, which produce collagen for the
structural foundation and framework upon which calcium and phosphate
are deposited, giving rise to tooth enamel.
- odontoblasts, which produce collagen for the
structual foundation and framework upon which calcium and phosphate
are deposited, giving rise to the inner part of the tooth. This
material is called dentin.
Like other proteins, collagen is composed of amino
acids linked together in a chain. However, collagen contains two
additional amino acids, hydroxyproline and hydroxylysine, not found
in other proteins. Thus when collagen breaks down, the hydroxyproline
and hydroxylysine levels in the blood and urine increase.
Researchers from Harvard University and the National Institutes
of Health knew in the 1960s that fluoride disrupted collagen synthesis.
It was not until 1979-1981, however, that a new flurry of research
activity in this area began.
In 1981, Dr. Kakuya Ishida of the Kanagawa Dental University in
Japan reported the results of studies in which he fed laboratory
animals 1 part per million fluoride in their drinking water and
analyzed the urine for hydroxyproline. He found that urinary hydroxyproline
levels increased in those animals. This indicates that as little
as 1 part per million fluoride interferes with collagen metabolism
and leads to its breakdown.
Dr. Marian Drozdz and co-workers from the Institute of Bioanalytical
and Environmental Studies in Katowice, Poland found increased hydroxyproline
and hydroxylysine levels in the blood and urine as well as a decrease
in skin and lung collagen levels in rats fed 1 part per million
fluoride in their drinking water.
Dr. Anna Put and co-workers from the Department of Pharmacology
of the Pomorska Akademy of Medicine in Szczecin, Poland also found
that fluoride increased hydroxyproline levels in urine.
Drs. A.K. Susheela, Y.D. Sharma and co-workers from the All-India
Institute of Medical Sciences found that fluoride exposure disrupts
the synthesis of collagen and leads to the breakdown of collagen
in bone, tendon, muscle, skin, cartilage, lung, kidney, and trachea.
As already noted, small vesicles transport collagen from the inside
of the cell to the outside of the cell. Drs. Harold Fleming and
Val Greenfield of Yale University School of Medicine found a larger
number of these vesicles in collagen forming cells (ameloblasts)
in animals exposed to fluoride. This work was recently confirmed
by S. Chen and D. Eisenmann of the University of Illinois, who also
found a fluoride-induced increase of these granules in ameloblasts.
It appears that fluoride disruption of collagen synthesis in cells
responsible for laying down collagen leads these cells to try to
compensate for their inability to put out intact collagen by producing
larger quantities of imperfect collagen and/or noncollagenous protein.
In 1983, Dr. John R. Farley and co-workers from Loma Linda University
showed that treatment of bone cells with less than 1 part per million
fluoride increased collagen formation by 50 percent. One year later,
Dr. J.R. Smid and co-workers from the Department of Oral Biology
at the University of Queensland in Australia found that fluoride
ingestion led to an increase of noncollagen proteins as well as
collagen proteins.
This is supported by the works of Drs. J.H. Bowes and M.M. Murray,
Dr. Kh.A. Abishev and co-workers, and Dr. B.R. Bhussry who report
a vastly higher protein content in teeth and bone damaged by fluoride.
Clinical findings also show that new irregular bone growth is stimulated
by fluoride.
The drawings below illustrate the effect of fluoride on collagen
metabolism.
While collagen is made by many different types of cells and, under
normal circumstances, is only mineralized in teeth and bones, the
body obviously has some mechanism to mineralize the collagen of
some tissues while leaving the collagen of other tissues, such as
skin, ligaments, tendons, etc., unmineralized.
During the aging process, the body loses its ability to discriminate
between which tissues should be mineralized and which tissues should
not. As will be shown, consumption of fluoride results in the same
loss of the body's ability to discriminate. In other words, mineralization
of tissue, such as bone, which should be mineralized, is disrupted,
and tendons, ligaments, muscles, and other soft tissue which should
not be mineralized start to become mineralized as a result of fluoride
exposure.
By interfering with collagen production, fluoride leads to the production
of larger quantites of imperfect collagen and/or other types of
protein and thus interferes with the body's normal regulation of
collagen mineralization.
The type and array of collagen and collagen-related proteins made
by the various collagen-producing cells determine whether or not
the collagen framework will be mineralized. During the aging process,
cumulative damage to these cells leads to the diseases attributed
to "old age" - arthritis, arteriosclerosis, brittle bones,
wrinkled skin, etc. Consumption of fluoride produces the same effects
and results in the same diseases.
Fluoride probably acts by interfering with enzymes essential for
setting up the proper conditions for producing intact collagen.
Thus, as has already been indicated, larger amounts of imperfect
or deformed collagen fibers are formed and the body's ability to
regulate collagen formation and mineralization is hindered...
Chapter 6 - Aging the Bone: The Degenerative
Effects of Skeletal Fluorosis
Now let's look at the bone. Unlike the ameloblasts, and odontoblasts
of teeth whose regenerative activity stops after tooth development,
osteoblasts continue to actively lay down collagen, and new bone
formation continues to take place.
If a tooth breaks or fractures, you're out of luck. The damage cannot
be repaired. However, if a bone breaks or fractures, osteoblasts
lay down collagen to produce a framework for new bone formation
to repair the damage.
Bone also has the ability to rejuvenate itself. As older bone is
removed by bone scavenger cells called osteoclasts, osteoblasts
lay down collagen to produce a framework for new bone formation
to renew the skeletal structure.
Thus, damage to collagen production in bone can interfere with the
normal processes of bone rejuvenation and repair throughout life.
Cartilage
The balls and sockets of bones are lined with a smooth, tough elastic
substance called cartilage. Maintaining the integrity of cartilage
depends largely upon the ability of cells called chondroblasts to
lay down noncalcified collagen which is the major structural component
of cartilage.
The Effect of Fluoride on Bone and Cartilage
Fluoride has been shown to interfere with collagen formation in
osteoblasts and chondroblasts. If, as pointed out, increased production
of imperfect collagen or collagen-like protein results in mineralization
of tissues which should not be mineralized, and vice versa, one
would expect a calcification of ligaments, cartilage, and tendons
as well as the formation of poorly and overly mineralized bone.
This is exactly what happens after exposure to fluoride.
In discussing their examination of tissues from patients exposed
to fluoride, Drs. A. Singh and S.S. Jolly, world-renowned experts
on the clinical effects of fluoride on bone, point out that:
- The most noticeable changes are detected in the spine with calcification
of various spinal ligaments, resulting in pronounced bony outgrowths.
The other bones show numerous spiky outgrowths especially in tendons
(collagen-rich fibrous tissue which attach muscles to bone) and
ligaments (collagen rich fibrous tissue which holds bones together).
Under careful inspection, the bony outgrowths are found to consist
of coarse, woven fibers which are largely uncalcified.
- Irregular bone is also laid down in joint sockets...
and interosseous membranes (membranes between bones
in arms and legs).
- In more advanced cases of fluoride exposure,
bones become held together by masses of new bone laid down in the
joint socket, ligaments and tendons. This results in the locking
up of joints and permanent inability of victims to move or flex
their joints. Vertebrae become fused at many places. This results
in the characteristic "hunch back" symptom of skeletal
fluorosis.
- There is a low degree of remineralization of
the bone itself, which is partly due to a wide seam of uncalcified
osteoid (collagen).
In 1973, Dr. Jolly and co-workers presented radiological
evidence of skeletal fluorosis which results in these bone deformities
in parts of India where the drinking
water contained as little as 0.7 parts per million fluoride, with
the occurrence and severity increasing with increasing levels of
fluoride in the drinking water.
RADIOLOGICAL
EVIDENCE OF SKELETAL FLUOROSIS IN MALES 21 YEARS OF AGE AND
OLDER |
Village |
Water Fluoride (ppm) |
Percentage |
Mandi Baretta |
.7 |
2.8 |
Kooriwara |
2.3 |
40.0 |
Gurnay Kalan |
2.4 |
19.6 |
Ganza Dhanaula |
4.2 |
26.3 |
Bajakhana |
5.1 |
46.9 |
Rajia |
5.2 |
52.2 |
Village Baretta |
5.5 |
29.6 |
Rorki |
7.0 |
52.5 |
Saideke |
8.2 |
52.6 |
Khara |
9.4 |
80.1 |
In 1985, Dr. I. Arnala and co-workers of Kuopio
University in Finland reported that: "The upper limit for
fluoride concentration in drinking water that does not increase
the amount of unmineralized bone is roughly 1.5 parts per million.
...We should however, recognize that it is difficult to give a strict
value for a safe concentration in drinking water because individual
susceptibility to fluoride varies."
In addition to fluoride-induced bone irregularities, one could expect
that the fluoride-induced irregularities of the joint cartilage
(which is normally smooth) would result in the irritation and inflammation
commonly referred to as arthritis. One could also expect fluoride
to cause an increase in the incidence of fractures and a decrease
in the body's ability to heal bone breaks and bone fractures.
Clinical observations show that this is exactly what happens.
Arthritic Changes
Drs. Singh and Jolly point out that early symptoms of fluoride-induced
damage to bones and cartilage start with "vague pains noted
most frequently in the small joints of the spine. These cases are
frequent in the endemic [local] areas and may be misdiagnosed
as rheumatoid or osteoarthritis.
"In later stages, there is an obvious stiffness of the spine
with limitation of movements, and still later, the development of
kyphosis [hunch back].
"There is difficulty in walking, due partly to stiffness and
limitation of the movements of various joints....
"Some patients complain of dyspnea, [difficulty in breathing]
on exertion because of the rigidity of the thoracic cage."
Dr. Jolly and co-workers reported these symptoms in parts of India
where the drinking water contains as little as 0.7 parts per million
fluoride, the occurrence and severity increasing as the fluoride
content in the drinking water increased.
In the United States, Dr. George Waldbott also diagnosed some of
the early symptoms listed above, including arthritis and joint pains,
as being due to the consumption of water fluoridated at 1 part per
million. He was able to bring about a reversal in these symptoms
by eliminating fluoridated water from the patients'diets. However,
if left unattended, the degeneration leads to the advanced stages
of arthritis and "old age."
Similar arthritic symptoms have been reported among people exposed
to air-borne fluoride in Switzerland, Germany, Britain, United States,
Canada, and North Africa. Dr. Yiamouyiannis was contacted by an
independent British broadcasting company who consulted him concerning
a problem they had found in a brick manufacturing area about 50
miles outside of London where they reported that over 90% of the
population was suffering from arthritis induced by air-borne fluoride.
Dr.Waldbott noted the possibility of the age-accelerating effects
of fluoride with respect to arthritis and stated:
"Among the elderly, arthritis of the spine is an especially
common ailment that is customarily attributed to 'aging.' Since
fluoride retention in bones increases as a person grows older, how
can we disregard the possibility that this 'old age' disease might
be linked with fluoride intake? For example ... [others have] described
in detail X-ray changes encountered in skeletal fluorosis in North
Africa, that are in every respect identical to those present in
the arthritic spine of the elderly."
Breaks and Fractures
In 1978, Dr. J.A. Albright and co-workers from Yale University reported
at the Annual Meeting of the Orthopedics Research Society that as
little as 1 part per million fluoride decreases bone strength and
elasticity.
In 1983, Dr. B. Uslu from Anadelu University School of Medicine
in Eskisehir, Turkey reported that addition of fluoride to the drinking
water of rats with fractured bones resulted in defective healing
of the fracture due to disruption of collagen synthesis.
In 1978, the Journal of the American Medical Association published
an editorial pointing out that "in several short-term studies,
fluoride has been administered for treatment of involutional osteoporosis,
alone or with supplemental calcium, vitamin D or both. No studies
have demonstrated alleviation of fracture[s]. ... However, studies
in humans have shown an increased incidence of... fractures. When
high doses of fluorides have been given to animals receiving a diet
that was otherwise unchanged, most studies have shown no change
or a decrease in the strength of the bone." They also
pointed out that administration of fluoride resulted in nonmineralized
seams in bones, resulting in the disease called osteomalacia. These
nonmineralized seams imply that breaks and fractures in the patients'
bones would tend to heal more slowly.
It is ironic that anyone would ever think of treating osteoporosis
(a disease in which the bones lose calcium) with fluoride, a substance
which leads to decalcification of bone. In 1977, Dr. Jennifer Jowsey,
one of the originators of fluoride therapy for osteoporosis, admitted
that fluoride was leading to a greater degree of osteoporosis (demineralization)
in some bones while leading to osteosclerosis (overmineralization)
in others. In other words, fluoride treatment of osteoporosis "robs
Peter to pay Paul" and leads to a general weakening of the
bones.
In 1980, Dr. J.C. Robin and co-workers from the Roswell Park Memorial
Institute confirmed the foolishness of using fluoride for the treatment
of osteoporosis by publishing their results in the Journal
of Medicine. According to the authors, "fluoride
had no preventive effect. In some experiments there was even a deleterious
effect of fluoride." They found fluoride accelerated the
process of osteoporosis leading to a loss of calcium from the bone.
Claims that the amount of fluoride found in fluoridated water would
help prevent osteoporosis have been studied epidemiologically. Researchers
from the U.S. National Center for Health Statistics claimed to find
no preventive effect, while researchers from the National Board
of Health in Finland claim to find a preventive effect. However,
the number of people examined in these two studies was far too small
to yield statistically meaningful results. The studies of Drs. Singh
and Jolly as well as the studies of Dr. I. Arnala and co-workers
who report increases in unmineralized bone, are consistent with
the finding of Dr. Robin that fluoride accelerates the process of
osteoporosis.
In 1973, a report from the National Institute of Arthritis and Metabolic
Diseases found 50 to 100% increases in the incidence of a disease
called osteitis fibrosa among patients whose artificial kidney machines
were run on fluoridated water. Osteitis fibrosa is a disease characterized
by fibrous degeneration of the bone; it results in bone deformities
and sometimes in fracture...
Hardening of the Arteries
In a number of areas where people consume water
containing 3 parts per million fluoride or more, calcification of
the arteries has been clinically correlated with the fluoride-induced
bone disorders described in Chapter 6. The indication again is that
fibroblasts in the arterial cell walls are producing larger amounts
of an imperfect collagen or collagen-like protein, resulting in
hardening of the arteries or arteriosclerosis, the leading cause
of death in the United States.
During aging, hardening of the arteries is probably
due to disruption of collagen production, according to Dr. John
Negalesko, director of the first year medical program at the Ohio
State University Medical School and an expert in the field. Thus,
fluoride, by disrupting the production of collagen and by stimulating
the calcification of arteries, has speeded up another phase of the
aging process...
Chapter 8: Fluoride & Genetic Damage
As pointed out in Chapter 4, all animals, including humans, are
made up of cells. Each cell contains a nucleus, which is separated
from the remainder of the cell by a nuclear membrane. Within the
nucleus exist chromosomes, which contain DNA and protein. DNA is
the body's master blueprint material. It is the genetic material
that determines how the body is built. DNA specifies traits such
as height, hair texture and color, number of fingers on each hand,
blood type, and by means of its control of protein and enzyme synthesis,
the susceptibility of the individual to various diseases.
Since maintaining the integrity of this master blueprint is so vital,
the cell makes a "photocopy" of the DNA called RNA, so
that the risk of damaging the DNA is minimized. This photocopy blueprint
is taken to "construction sites" in the cell. These construction
sites are called ribosomes. On these ribosomes, the RNA blueprint
is used to direct the manufacture of proteins and enzymes, which,
in turn, directly determine the structure, traits, and limiting
capabilities of the body.
To further insure the integrity of DNA, the cell provides a group
of enzymes called the DNA repair enzyme system which repairs DNA
when damage is done to it. As people age, their DNA repair enzyme
system slows down. This results in DNA damage which goes unrepaired
and leads to cell damage or death. Damaged or dead cells may then
put out products which in turn damage other cells, leading eventually
to massive cell death and the degenerative loss of various tissues
and organs in a snowballing cycle of aging > damage > aging
....
Serious consequences can also arise if the unrepaired DNA damage
occurs in a cell which gives rise to a sperm or egg cell. In these
cases, DNA damage in the defective egg or sperm cell will be replicated
in every cell of the offspring's body and will lead to a birth defect.
If the child with this birth defect survives to maturity and reproduces,
this genetic deformity will be passed on from generation to generation.
A decline in DNA repair activity with "age" is one of
the reasons why the number of birth defects increases as maternal
age increases.
Unrepaired damage of a segment of the DNA responsible for control
of cell growth (brought about by a deficient DNA repair enzyme system)
can lead to uncontrolled cell growth or tumors. Many tumors stop
growing when they are contained by the cells around them. However,
in some cases, tumor cells may release an enzyme, or may be induced
by additional genetic damage to release an enzyme, which digests
the surrounding cells. The result is an invasive or malignant tumor
and is more commonly referred to as cancer.
An excellent example of a defective DNA repair enzyme system leading
to cancer is provided by victims of a disease called xeroderma pigmentosum.
These people suffer from an inherited deficiency of DNA repair enzyme
activity and are known to succumb to cancer early in life as a result.
A decline in DNA repair activity with "age" is one of
the primary reasons why the incidence of cancer among older people
is so much higher than the cancer incidence among younger people.
The defective DNA repair enzyme in patients with xeroderma pigmentosum
accelerates the aging process to the extent that xeroderma pigmentosum
patients in their 20's have the same cancer risk as "normal"
people in their 80's.
Dr. Wolfgang Klein and co-workers at the Seibersdorf Research Center
in Austria reported that 1 part per million fluoride inhibits DNA
repair enzyme activity by 50%. Since fluoride inhibits DNA repair
enzyme activity, fluoride should also be expected to lead to an
increase in genetic or chromosome damage.
This has indeed been found to occur in numerous studies showing
that fluoride in water, even at the concentration of 1 part per
million, can cause chromosome damage.
The following table outlines the results of laboratory studies regarding
the effect of fluoride on genetic damage in mammals.
Year |
Institution |
Animal |
Findings |
1973 |
Russian Research Institute of Industrial Health
& Occupational Diseases (USSR) |
rat |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
1974 |
Columbia University College of Physicians
& Surgeons (USA) |
mouse/sheep/cow |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
1978 |
Pomeranian Medical Academy (Poland) |
human WBCs |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
1979 |
National Institute of Dental Research (USA)* |
mouse |
fluoride does not cause genetic damage* |
1981 |
Institute of Botany, Baku (USSR) |
rat 3 studies |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
1982 |
University of Missouri, Kansas City (USA) |
mouse |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
1983 |
Kunming Institute of Zoology, Kunming (Peop.
Rep. China) |
deer |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
1983 |
Kunming Institute of Zoology, Kunming (Peop.
Rep. China) |
human WBCs |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
1984 |
Nippon Dental University, Tokyo (Japan) |
hamster embryo cell |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
1984 |
Nippon Dental University, Tokyo (Japan) |
human cell culture |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
1985 |
Medical Research Council, Edinburgh (UK) |
human WBCs |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
*A prepublication copy of this paper was submitted
as an exhibit in a court case in Pittsburgh (USA). During trial,
it was brought out that the results showed that increasing fluoride
contents in drinking water increased genetic damage in mouse testes
cells. Before the paper was published these figures were altered
so as to destroy the original figures showing a relation between
fluoride and genetic damage (see Chapter 16).
One of the most relevant of these studies are those of Dr. Aly Mohamed,
a geneticist at the University of Missouri. They show that one part
per million fluoride in the drinking water of mice causes chromosomal
damage. These studies also show that as the fluoride content of
the water increases the degree of chromosomal damage increases in
both testes and bone marrow. The results are presented in the following
table:
(Click to enlarge table)
Chromosomes (and thus any chromosomal abnormalities that may occur)
are only visible while the cell is dividing. Therefore, Dr. Mohamed
studied bone marrow and testes cells since these cells divide rapidly.
Since the testes cells observed by Dr. Mohamed give rise to sperm
cells which are passed on to future generations, genetic damage
to these testes cells can lead to birth defects and other metabolic
disorders which can be passed on from generation to generation.
Early studies regarding the ability of fluoride to cause chromosome
damage were done on plants and insects and as a result drew little
attention. However, since the basic structure, function, and repair
of chromosomes is similar in plants, insects, and animals, substances
like fluoride which cause genetic damage in plants and insects,
will most likely cause genetic damage in animals-including man.
The following table outlines the results of laboratory studies regarding
the effect of fluoride on genetic damage in plants and insects.
Year |
Institution |
Plant or Insect Used |
Findings |
1966 |
Texas A&M University (USA) |
Onion |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
1966 |
Texas A&M University (USA) |
Tomato |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
1968 |
University of Missouri, Kansas City (USA) |
Tomato |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
1970 |
University of Missouri, Kansas City (USA) |
Maize |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
1970 |
University of Missouri, Kansas City (USA) |
Fruit Fly |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
1971 |
Texas A&M University (USA) |
Fruit Fly |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
1973 |
Texas A&M University (USA) |
Fruit Fly |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
1973 |
Central Laboratory for Mutagen Testing (W.
Germany) |
Fruit Fly |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
1973 |
Texas A&M University (USA) |
Barley (2) |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
1982 |
Institute of Botany, Baku (USSR) |
Onion |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
1983 |
Institute of Botany, Baku (USSR) |
Onion |
fluoride causes genetic damage |
Drs. R.N. Mukherjee and F.H. Sobels from the University
of Leiden in Holland found that fluoride increased the frequency
of genetic damage in sperm cells which were produced by laboratory
animals exposed to X-rays. It is evident, from their studies, that
fluoride inhibited the repair of DNA damaged X-rays. The authors
themselves concluded: "sodium fluoride resulted in a consistent
and highly significant increase of the mutation [i.e. genetic
damage] frequency. This effect is thought to result from interference
with a repair process."
In agreement with Drs. Mukheijee and Sobels were Dr. S.I. Voroshilin
and co-workers from the Russian Research Institute of Industrial
Health and Occupational Diseases. From their studies they concluded:
"It would seem to us that fluoride could cause some kind of
disturbance in the enzymes that are related to the mechanisms of
DNA repair and synthesis."
In 1981, Dr. A. Iarez and co-workers from the Department of Toxicology
from Central University ofVenezuela in Caracas, reported that fluoride
added to the drinking water of female rats produced birth defects
in their offspring. Just one year later Drs. Rhuitao Zhang and Shunguang
Zhang of the Changjian Institute of Marine Products found that fluoride
caused birth defects in fish.
According to the June 16, 1976 issue of the San Diego Union, an
experiment showed that 10% of the litters of female mice drinking
tap water from Durham, North Carolina (fluoridated in 1962) contained
at least one malformed baby. No birth defects were observed in mice
drinking purified water. While this study in itself does not prove
that fluoride was the cause, the effects of fluoride as determined
by the investigators mentioned above certainly make fluoride a prime
suspect.
Fluoride-Induced Cancer
The ability of fluoride to cause genetic damage is so well recognized
that investigators are now trying to find ways to counteract its
genetic damaging effects.
Substances like fluoride which cause genetic damage are called mutagenic
substances and it is a well-accepted fact that substances which
are mutagenic also tend to be carcinogenic, or cancer producing.
In fact, this is exactly what has been found with regard to fluoride.
Dr. Takeki Tsutsui and co-workers of the Nippon Dental College in
Japan showed that fluoride not only caused genetic damage but was
also capable of transforming normal cells into cancer cells. The
levels of fluoride used in this study were the same levels of fluoride
that the U.S. National Cancer Institute suggested should be used
to determine whether or not fluoridation of public water supplies
causes cancer.
They found that cells treated with 34 and 45 parts per million fluoride
produced cancer (fibrosarcoma) when injected under the skin of otherwise
healthy adult hamsters. In contrast, they found that cells that
were not treated with fluoride did not produce cancer.
This confirms the earlier U.S. National Cancer Institute sponsored
studies done by Drs. Irwin Herskowitz and Isabel Norton. In 1963,
these St. Louis University scientists showed that low levels of
fluoride increased the incidence of melanotic tumors in fruit flies
by 12 to 100% (see the following figure).
(Click here
to enlarge)
Similar types of transformations of normal cells
to potentially cancerous cells have been observed in humans.
Dr. Danuta Jachimczak and co-workers from the Pomeranian Medical
Academy in Poland reported that as little as 0.6 part per million
fluoride produces chromosomal damage in human white blood cells.
This study has received support from two other studies by Dr. R.
Lin and co-workers from the Kumming Institute of Zoology and Dr.
E.J. Thomson and co-workers from the Medical Research Council in
Edinburgh, Scotland, who showed a 2-fold to 15-fold increase in
chromosomal aberration rates at levels of 1.5 to 60 parts per million
fluoride. The Thomson study suffers from the fact that the investigators
administered another mutagenic substance to all the cells tested
to measure other indexes of chromosomal activity.
Dr. Stephen Greenberg from the Chicago Medical School observed a
disturbance of the DNA in white blood cells of animals treated with
5-10 ppm fluoride and observed other changes which he maintained
were characteristic of cancer cells. In humans, Dr. Paul H. Duffey
and co-workers from the Tucson Medical Center also found that fluoride
transforms certain white blood cells into cells which appeared to
be cancerous.
It is quite clear that fluoride causes genetic damage. The mechanism
of action of fluoride cannot be exactly pinpointed because fluoride
interferes with a number of physiological processes. Most evidence
indicates that fluoride acts on the DNA repair enzyme system. This
does not rule out the possibility that fluoride also interferes
with DNA synthesis or that it may even act directly on the DNA itself.
DNA is composed of two molecular strands held together by hydrogen
bonds and fluoride is capable of disrupting these bonds. Such disruption
would be expected to result in genetic damage directly and/or interference
with DNA synthesis and DNA repair.
Furthermore, fluoride-induced genetic damage may also result from
the general metabolic imbalance caused by fluoride selectively inhibiting
certain enzymes.
The fact that fluoride has also been shown to cause cancer should
not be surprising since it is almost universally accepted that cancer
results from genetic damage.
In any event, the fact that fluoride disrupts DNA repair enzyme
activity, the fact that fluoride causes genetic damage, and the
fact that fluoride causes cancer shows again that fluoride is directly
accelerating the aging process.
REFERENCES:
Chapter 4: Breaking Down the Body's Glue
L. Golub, et al., "The Effect of Sodium Fluoride on the Rates
of Synthesis and Degradation of Bone Collagen in Tissue Culture,"
Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Biology and Medicine,
Volume 129, pp. 973-977 (1968).
W.A. Peck, et al., "Fluoride Inhibition of Bone Collagen Synthesis,"
Clinical Research, Volume 13, p. 330 (1965).
Kakuya Ishida, "The Effects of Fluoride on Bone Metabolism,"
Koku Eisei Gakkai Zasshi, Volume 31, No. 2, pp. 74-78 (1981).
Marian Drozdz, et al., "Studies on the Influence of Fluoride
Compounds upon Connective Tissue Metabolism in Growing Rats,"
Toxicological European Research, Volume 3, No. 5, pp. 237, 239-241
(1981).
Marian Drozdz, et al., "Studies on the Influence of Fluoride
Compounds upon Connective Tissue Metabolism in Growing Rats. 11.
Effect of Sodium Fluoride With and Without Simultaneous Exposure
to Hydrogen Fluoride on Collagen Metabolism," J. Toxicol. Med.,
Volume 4, pp. 151-157 (1984).
Anna Put, et al., "Effect of Chronic Administration of Sodium
Fluoride and Calcium Carbonate on Some Biochemical Changes in Rats,"
Bromatol. Chem. Toksykol., Volume 16, pp. 219-224 (1983).
Wieslawa Jarzynka and Anna Put, "Effect of Chronic Fluoride
Poisoning on the Morphological Appearance of Dentin in White Rats,"
Czas. Stoma., Volume 37, pp. 169-175 (1984).
A.K. Susheela and Mohan Jha, "Effect of Fluoride on Cortical
and Cancellous Bone Composition," IRCS Medical Sciences: Library
Compendium, Volume 9, No. 11, pp. 1021-1022 (1981).
Y.D. Sharma, "Effect of Sodium Fluoride on Collagen Cross-link
Precursors," Toxicological Letters, Volume 10, pp. 97-100 (1982).
A.K. Susheela and D. Mukerjee, "Fluoride Poisoning and the
Effect of Collagen Biosynthesis of Osseous and Nonosseous Tissues
of Rabbit," Toxicological European Research, Volume 3, No.
2, pp. 99-104 (1981).
Y.D. Sharma, "Variations in the Metabolism and Maturation of
Collagen after Fluoride Ingestion,"Biochimica et Biophysica
Acta, Volume 715, pp. 137-141 (1982).
Harold Fleming and Val Greenfield, "Changes in the Tbeth and
Jaws of Neonatal Webster Mice After Administration of Sodium Fluoride
and Calcium Fluoride to the Female Parent During Gestation,"
Journal of Dental Research, Volume 33, No. 6, pp. 780-788 (1954).
S. Chen and D. Eisenmann, "Calcium Shifts in Ameloblasts During
Experimentally Altered Enamel Formation," Journal of Dental
Research, Volume 6, p. 372 (1985).
John R. Farley, et al., "Fluoride Directly Stimulates Proliferation
and Alkaline Phosphatase Activity of Bone Forming Cells," Science,
Volume 222, pp. 330-332 (1983).
J.R. Smid, et al., "Effect of Long-Tbrm Administration of Fluoride
on the Levels of EDTA-Soluble Protein and Gamma CarWxyglutamic Acid
in Rat Incisor Teeth,"Journal ofDentalResearch, Volume 63,
pp. 1061-1063 (1984).
J.H. Bowes and M.M. Murray, "A Chemical Study of 'Mottled Teeth'
from Maldon, Essex," British Dental Journal, Volume 60, pp.
556-562 (1936).
Kh. A. Abishev, et al., "Molecular Composition of Bones During
Chronic Fluoride Poisoning," Zdravookr. Kaz, Volume 30, No.
5, pp. 28-30 (1971).
B.R. Bhussry, "Chemical and Physical Studies ofEnamel from
Human Teeth,", Journal of Dental Research, Volume 38, pp. 369-373
(1959).
M. Soriano, "Periostitis Deformans Due to Wine Fluorosis,"
Fluoride, Volume 1, pp. 56-64 (1968).
Chapter 6: Aging the Bone: The Degenerative Effects of Fluoride
Amarjit Singh and S.S. Jolly, "Chronic'fbxic Effects on the
Skeletal System," Fluorides and Human Health, World Health
Organization, Geneva, Switzerland, 1970, pp. 238-249.
Amarjit Singh, et al., "Skeletal Changes in Endemic Fluorosis,"
Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, Volume 44 B, No. 4, pp. 806-815
(1962).
S.S. Jolly, et al., "Endemic Fluorosis in Punjab," Fluoride,
Volume 6, pp. 4-18 (1973).
George Waldbott, et al., Fluoridation: The Great Dilemma, Coronado
Press, Lawrence, Kansas, 1978, 423 pp.
J.A. Albright, "Me Effect of Fluoride on the Mechanical Properties
of Bone," 7),ansactions of the Annual Meeting of the Orthopedics
Research Society, 1978, pp. 3, 98.
B. Uslu, "Effect of Fluoride on Collagen Synthesis in the Rat,"
Research in Experimental Medicine, Volume 182, pp. 7-12 (1983).
Stephen Marks, "Restraint and Use of High-Dose Fluorides to
Treat Skeletal Disorders," Journal of the American Medical
Association, Volume 240, No. 15, pp. 1630-1631 (1978).
Jennifer Jowsey, Comments made at the 1977 National Convention of
the American Association of the Advancement of Science in Denver,
Colorado.
J.C. Robin, et al., "Studies on Osteoporosis Ill. Effect of
Estrogens and Fluoride," Journal of Medicine, Volume 11, No.
1, pp. 1-14 (1980).
J.C. Robin and J.L. Ambrus, "Studies on Osteoporosis IX. Effect
of Fluoride on Steroid Induced Osteoporosis," Research Communications
in Chemical Pathology and Pharmacology, Volume 37, No. 3, pp. 453-461
(1982).
Jennifer Madans, et al., "The Relationship between Hip Fracture
and Water Fluoridation: An Analysis of National Data," American
Journal of Public Health, Volume 73, pp. 296-298 (1983).
Olli Simonen and Ossi Laitinen, "Does Fluoridation of Drinking
Water Prevent Bone Fragility and Osteoporosis?"Lancet (August
24,1985), pp. 432-434.
Ilkka Arnala, et al., "Effect of Fluoride on Bone in Finland,"
Acta Orthopaedica Scandinavia, Volume 56, pp. 161-166 (1985).
P.E. Cordy, et al., "Bone Disease in Hemodialysis Patients
with Particular Reference to the Effect of Fluoride in Study of
Nutritional Requirements of Patients on Chronic Hemodialysis,"
National Institute of Arthritis and Metabolic Diseases, July 1973,
pp. 28-59. [Distributed by the National Technical Information Service
of the U.S. Department of Commerce]
[According to the April 23, 1980 issue of the Medical Tribune, page
7, it was found that even low doses of fluoride in osteoporosis
treatment cause rheumatic and gastrointestinal adverse reactions.
Severe vomiting occurred in two patients until fluoride levels were
reduced to 3.7 to 7.5 mg per day.]
L.J. Ream and P.B. Pendergrass, 'The Effects of Fluoride on the
Periosteal and Endosteal Surfaces of the Rat Femur," Journal
of Submicrosc. Cytology, Volume 14, No. 1, pp~ 81-91 (1982).
Chapter 8: Fluoride & Genetic Damage
John Little, "Relationship Between DNA Repair
Capacity and Cellular Aging," Gerontology, Volume 22, pp. 28-55
(1976).
Wolfgang Klein, et al., "DNA Repair and Environmental Substances,"
Zeitschrift fur AngewanilteRader und Klimaheilkunde, Volume 24,
No. 3, pp. 218-223 (1977).
Wolfgang Klein, et al., "Biochemical Research on the Action
of Sodium Fluoride on Mammalian Cells. The Effect on Biosynthesis
of Nucleic Acid and Proteins on Mouse Spleen Cells in in Vivo Studies,"
Report ofthe Austrian Society of Atomic Energy, Seibersdorf Research
Center, No. 2355, pp. 1-10 (1974).
Wolgang Klein, et al., "DNA Repair and Environmental Substances,"
Report of the Austrian Society of Atomic Energy, SeibersdorfResearch
Center, No. 2613, pp. 1-9 (1976).
S.I. Voroshilin, et al., "Cytogenetic Effect of Inorganic Fluorine
Compounds on Human and Animal Cells in Vivo and in Vitro,"
Genetika, Volume 9, No. 4, pp. 115-120 (1973).
Georgiana Jagiello and Ja-Shein Lin, "Sodium Fluoride as Potential
Mutagen in Mammalian Eggs," Archives of Environmental Health,
Volume 29, pp. 230-235(1974).
Danuta Jachimczak and Bogumila Skotarczak, "The Effect of Fluorine
and Lead Ions on the Chromosomes of Human Leucocytes in Vitro."
Genetica Polonica, Volume 19, No. 3, pp. 353-357 (1978).
George Martin, et al., "Lack of Cytogenetic Effect in Mice
or Mutations in Salmonella Receiving Sodium Fluoride," Mutation
Research, Volume 66, pp. 159-167 (1979).
A.A. Aliev and D.A.Babaev, "Cytogenetic Activity of Vitamins
in Bone Marrow Cells of Rat Femurs in Sodium Fluoride-Induced Mutation
Conditions," Tsitol. Genet., Volume 15, pp. 19-23 (1981).
A.A. Aliev, et al., "Effect of alpha-Ibeopherol on the Level
of Chromosome Aberrations Induced by Sodium Fluoride in Rat Femur
Bone Marrow Cells," Izv. Akad. Nauk Az. SSR Ser. Biol. Nauk.,
No. 1, pp. 17-20 (1981).
V. Yu Akhundov, et al., "Effect of Combined and Separate Exogenous
Vitamin Administration on the Level of Chromosomal Aberrations Induced
by Sodium Fluoride in Rats in Subacute Experiments," Izv. Akad.
Nauk Az. SSR, Ser. Biol. Nauk, No. 4, pp. 3-5 (1981).
Aly Mohamed and M.E. Chandler, "Cytological Effects of Sodium
Fluoride on Mice," Fluoride, Volume 15, No. 3, pp. 110-118
(1982).
Weishun He, et al., "Effect of Sodium Fluoride and Fluoroacetamide
on Sister Chromatid Exchanges and Chromosome Aberrations in Cultured
Red Muntjac Cells," Huanjing Kexue Xuebao, Volume 3, pp. 94-100
(1983).
Takeki Tsutsui, et al., "Sodium Fluoride-induced Morphological
and Neoplastic T~ansfbrmation, Chromosome Aberrations, Sister Chromatid
Exchanges, and Unscheduled DNA Synthesis in Cultured Syrian Hamster
Embryo Cells," Cancer Research, Volume 44, pp. 938-941 (1984).
Thkeki Tsutsui, et al., "Cytotoxicity, Chromosome Aberrations
and Unscheduled DNA Synthesis in Cultured Human Diploid Fibroblasts
Induced by Sodium Fluoride," Mutation Research, Volume 139,
pp. 193-198 (1984).
A.H. Mohamed, et al., "Cytological Reactions
Induced by Sodium Fluoride in Allium Cepa Root-Tip Chromosomes,"
Canadian Journal of Genetics and Cytology, Volume 8, pp. 241-244
(1966).'
A.H. Mohamed, et al., "Cytological Effects on Hydrogen Fluoride
on 'Ibmato Chromosomes," Canadian Journal of Genetics and Cytology,
Volume 8, pp. 575-583 (1966).
A.H. Mohamed, "Cytogenetic Effects of Hydrogen Fluoride Treatment
in `Ibmato Plants," Journal of the Air Pollution Control Association,
Volume 18, pp. 395-398 (1968).
A.H. Mohamed, "Chromosome Changes in Maize Induced by Fluorine
Gas," CanadianJournal ofGenetics andCytology, Volume 12,pp.
614-620(1970).
A.H. Mohamed, "Induced Recessive Lethals in Second Chromosomes
in Drosophila Melanogaster by Hydrogen Fluoride," Proceedings
of the Second International Clean Air Congress of the International
Union ofAir Pollution Prevention Associations, 1970, p. 26.
R.A. Gerdes, et al., "The Effects of Atmospheric Hydrogen Fluoride
upon Drosophila Melanogaster," Atmospheric Environ., Volume
5, pp. 113-122 (1971).
B. Mitchell and R.A. Gerdes, "Mutagenic Effects of Sodium Fluoride
and Stannous Fluoride on Drosophila Melanogaster," Fluoride,
Volume 6, pp. 113-117 (1973).
E. Vogel, "Strong Antimutagenic Effects of Fluoride on Mutation
Induction by Trenimon and 1-Phenyl-3, 3-Dimethyltriazene in Drosophila
Melanogaster," Mutation Research, Volume 20, pp. 339-352 (1973).
S.S. Bale and G.E. Hart, "Cytogenetic and Genetic Effects of
Fluoride on Barley. I. Comparative Study of the Effects of Sodium
Fluoride and Hydrofluoric Acid on Seedling Root Tips," Canadian
Journal of Genetics and Cytology, Volume 15, pp. 695-702 (1973).
S.S. Bale and G.E. Hart, "Cytogenetic and Genetic Effects of
Fluoride on Barley. IL Effects of Treatments of Seedling Coleoptiles
with Sodium Fluoride," Canadian Journal of Genetics and Cytology,
Volume 15, pp. 703712(1973).
A.A. Aliev, et al., "Cytogenetic Effect of Sodium Fluoride
Treatment ofAllium Fistulosurn L. Seeds," Izv. Akad. Nauk Az.
SSR, Ser. Biol. Nauk, No. 2, pp. 8-10 (1982).
G.K. Ragamova, et al., "Features of the Modifying Capacity
of Mutations in Aegilops Seed Produced Under Various Ecological
Conditions," Izv. Akad. Nauk Az. SSR, Ser. Biol. Nauk, No.
4, pp. 21-24 (1983).
R.N. Mukheijee and F.H. Sobels, "Me Effect of Sodium Fluoride
and Iodoacetamide on Mutation Induction by X-Irradiation in Mature
Spermatozoa of Drosophila," Mutation Research, Volume 6, pp.
217-225 (1968).
A. larez, et al., "Sodium Fluoride, Fetotoxicity, and Oral
Experimental Teratogeny in Rats," Thricological Aspects [9th
Annual Symposium of the International Congress of the European Association
of Poison Control Centers], 1981, pp. 528-540.
Ruitao Zhang and Shunguang Zhang, "Ibxicity of Fluoride to
Fish," Huangjing Kexue, Volume 3, pp. 1-5 (1983).
Irwin Herskowitz & Isabel Norton, "Increased Incidence of Melanotic Tumors in Two Strains of Drosophila Melanogaster Following Treatment with Sodium Fluoride," Genetics, Volume 48, pp. 307-310 (1963).
Danuta Jachimzcak and Bogumila Skotarczak, "The Effect of Fluorine and Lead Ions on the Chromosomes of Human Leucocytes in Vitro," Genetica Polonica, Volume 19, No. 3, pp. 353-357 (1978).
Stephen Greenberg, "The Reaction of Mouse Leukocytes to Long-Term Fluoride Exposure," Anatomical Record, Volume 196, No. 2, pp. 266-267 (1980).
Stephen Greenberg, "Leukocyte Response in Young Mice Chronically
Exposed to Fluoride," Fluoride, Volume 15, No. 3, pp. 119-123
(1982).
Paul Duffey, et al., "Giant Cells in Bone Marrows of Patients
on High-Dose Fluoride Treatment," Annals of Internal Medicine,
Volume 75, pp. 745--747 (1971).
Listed below are some additional related references:
Nobutake Kanematsu, "Genetic Toxicity of Biomaterial. DNA Damaging
Effects of Sodium Fluoride and Other Fluoride Compounds," Japanese
Journal of Oral Biology, Volume 27, pp. 372-374 (1985).
V. Ya. Nikiforova, "Mechanism of the Mutagenic Action of Fluoride,"
Tsitol. Genet., Volume 16, pp. 40-42 (1982).
L.S. Strochkova, et al., "Effect of Fluoride on Morphological
and Metabolic Modifications in Hela Cell Culture," Tsitologiya,
Volume 26, pp. 299-306 (1984).
Thshio Imai, et al., "Effects of Fluoride on Cell Growth of
Two Human Cell Lines and on DNA and Protein Synthesis in Hela Cells,"
Acta Pharmacol. 7bxicol., Volume 52, pp. 8-11 (1983).
Kataoka Masayuki, "Effect of Sodium Fluoride on Blastogenesis
in Mouse Lymphocytes with Special Reference to the Uptake on 3H-Thymidine,
3 H-Uridine, or 'H-Leucine," Shika Gakuho, Volume 84, pp. 229-251
(1984).
Chong Chang, "Effect of Fluoride on Nucleotides and Ribonucleic Acid In Germinating Corn Seedling Roots," Plant Physiology, Volume 43, No. 5, pp. 669-674 (1968).
V.I. Shepotinovsky and Z.I. Mikashinovich, "Metabolic Response of Leukocytes as an Indicator of Animal Individual Reaction to Stress and Injury-Induced Shock,"Byull. Eksp. Biol. Med., Volume 90, No. 10, pp. 420-422 (1980).
Armando Moucdcy, "Histochemical (Glycogen, RNA, and Lipids) Studies of the Liver Cells of Rats Treated with Potable Water Containing Sodium Fluoride in Various Concentrations," Rev. Fac. Odontol. Univ. Sao Paulo, Volume 6, No. 3, pp. 197-215 (1968).
George Waldbott, et al., "Genetic Damage, Birth Defects, and Cancer," in Fluoridation: the Great Dilemma, Coronado Press, 1978, pp. 209-238.
John Remington Graham and Dean Burk, "Editorial Essay," Fluoride, Volume 17, pp. 63-69 (1984).
|